Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Sister Bay

Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille in Sister Bay, WI, is a true haven for pizza lovers and anyone craving vibrant, flavor-packed dishes served in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Specializing in hand-tossed, wood-fired pizzas, Wild Tomato delivers an authentic taste that’s both rustic and refined. From the moment you step inside, you’ll be greeted by the cozy energy of an open kitchen, where you can watch skilled pizzaiolos expertly toss dough and work the wood-fired oven to create crispy, smoky-crusted masterpieces.

The menu is a celebration of fresh, thoughtfully crafted ingredients and bold combinations. Signature offerings like the WOOD FIRED BREAD BASKET, a generous collection of cheesy pesto, parmesan olive tapenade flatbreads, garlic ciabatta, and parmesan knots served with marinara, balsamic oil, and herb mascarpone, set the tone for what’s to come—an unforgettable culinary journey. Fans rave about the FRIED CHEESE CURDS, perfectly hand-battered and fried to golden perfection, embodying Wisconsin’s proud cheese culture in every bite.

When it comes to pizza, the variety and quality shine. Whether you opt for a classic like the fresh and fragrant MARGHERITA PIZZA or a more adventurous choice like the THAI PIE bursting with unique flavors, each pie is a delicious testament to the art of wood-fired cooking. The crust strikes the perfect balance—crispy outside and tender inside—complemented by house-made organic tomato sauce and a luscious blend of mozzarella and smoked provolone cheeses.

Groups and indecisive diners will love the option to create a LARGE HALF & HALF pizza, combining two specialty flavors to satisfy diverse cravings. The popular LARGE DLUX, loaded with sausage, pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and colorful peppers topped with extra cheese, is hearty, flavorful, and immensely satisfying.

The dining experience extends beyond the food. Customers highlight the friendly, attentive service and the casual, relaxed vibe, whether dining inside or enjoying the outdoor picnic tables that offer a scenic Sister Bay backdrop. While wait times can be longer during peak hours—a testament to how sought-after this local gem is—regulars agree it’s well worth the anticipation. As one visitor perfectly put it, ordering a large pizza means you get to enjoy superb leftovers that taste just as amazing the next day.

Don’t miss the sweet finish with desserts like the classic NY STYLE CHEESECAKE topped with Door County cherries or the indulgent FLOURLESS CHOCOLATE CAKE paired with raspberry sauce. And if you’re a fan of creative twists, the DESSERT KNOTS—fried dough tossed in cinnamon sugar and served with pumpkin cream sauce—offer a warm, delightful finale to a memorable meal.

Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille is more than just a pizza place; it’s a celebration of quality, warmth, and culinary passion nestled in the heart of Sister Bay. Whether you’re a local or visiting for a special occasion, this spot promises a satisfying and vibrant dining experience that remains etched in your memory long after the last bite.